A2 Milk vs A1 Milk: Useful Health Benefits & Indian Brands

Milk is a vital part of the Indian diet, from morning chai to homemade sweets. Traditionally, Indian households consumed fresh cow or buffalo milk without giving much thought to the type of protein it contained. But in recent years, awareness has grown around A2 milk—touted as a healthier, more natural alternative to regular milk, which mostly contains A1 protein.

So, what is the difference between A1 and A2 milk, and which one should you choose for your family’s health? In this article, we’ll break down everything you need to know about A2 milk vs A1 milk in the Indian context, including health benefits, sources, nutritional value, and frequently asked questions.

You all know this Amul Song

A2 Milk vs A1 Milk: A simple comparison

The main difference between A1 and A2 milk lies in a specific protein called beta-casein, which makes up a significant portion of milk’s total protein content. Cow’s milk can contain either A1 beta-casein, A2 beta-casein, or a mix of both, depending on the breed of the cow.

• A1 milk contains A1 beta-casein, which may produce beta-casomorphin-7 (BCM-7) during digestion. This compound has been linked to various digestive issues in some people.
• A2 milk contains only A2 beta-casein, which does not produce BCM-7, making it potentially easier to digest.

Cow Breeds in India That Produce A2 Milk

India is blessed with several indigenous cow breeds that naturally produce A2 milk. These include:

• Gir
• Sahiwal
• Red Sindhi
• Tharparkar
• Rathi

On the other hand, foreign or crossbred cows like Holstein Friesian and Jersey commonly produce A1 or mixed (A1/A2) milk. Unfortunately, due to the push for higher milk yield, these exotic breeds have become more common in commercial dairy farming across India.

Nutritional Comparison: A2 Milk vs A1 Milk

Nutrient	A1 Milk	A2 Milk	Notes
Protein	3.3g/100ml	3.3g/100ml	Both contain similar levels of protein, including casein and whey
Fat	3.5g/100ml	3.5g/100ml	Fat content is comparable, but may vary by brand and processing
Carbohydrates	4.7g/100ml	4.7g/100ml	Primarily lactose in both varieties
Calcium	120mg/100ml	120mg/100ml	Both are excellent calcium sources
Vitamin D	0.1µg/100ml*	0.1µg/100ml*	*Unless fortified; fortified values vary by brand
Vitamin B12	0.4µg/100ml	0.4µg/100ml	Both provide similar amounts
Potassium	150mg/100ml	150mg/100ml	Electrolyte content is comparable
Phosphorus	95mg/100ml	95mg/100ml	Essential for bone health
Beta-casomorphin-7 (BCM-7)	Present	Minimal/None	Key differentiator; BCM-7 is a bioactive peptide that may affect digestion
Digestibility	May cause discomfort in sensitive individuals	Often better tolerated by those with milk sensitivity	Not related to lactose intolerance

The primary difference between A1 and A2 milk is not nutritional content but protein structure. A1 milk contains A1 beta-casein protein that breaks down into BCM-7 during digestion, while A2 milk contains only A2 beta-casein. This structural difference may impact digestibility for some people, though research is ongoing. From a purely nutritional standpoint, both provide similar vitamins, minerals, proteins, and energy.

Health Benefits: A2 Milk vs A1 Milk

It’s worth noting that while many claims exist about A2 milk’s superiority, research is still evolving. Individual responses to both milk types vary considerably, and personal experimentation may be necessary to determine which type works best for your body.

A2 Milk Health Benefits

1. Easier Digestion: Many people who experience digestive discomfort with regular milk report better tolerance with A2 milk, as it doesn’t produce the BCM-7 peptide during digestion.
2. Reduced Inflammatory Response: Some studies suggest A2 milk may cause less inflammation in the digestive system compared to A1 milk.
3. Better for Sensitive Stomachs: People with milk sensitivity (not lactose intolerance) often find A2 milk causes fewer symptoms like bloating, abdominal pain, and digestive discomfort.
4. May Support Digestive Health: Research indicates A2 milk might contribute to healthier gut transit times and better overall digestive function.
5. Traditional Genetic Profile: A2 milk comes from cows with the original beta-casein gene, representing the milk humans consumed before genetic mutations occurred in European herds.

A1 Milk Health Benefits

1. Complete Nutrition Profile: A1 milk provides all the essential nutrients milk is known for: calcium, protein, vitamins D and B12, and phosphorus.
2. Widespread Availability: More readily available and typically less expensive than A2 milk, making its nutritional benefits more accessible.
3. Familiar Taste Profile: Has the taste characteristics most consumers are accustomed to in dairy products.
4. Supports Bone Health: Like all milk, A1 milk is an excellent source of calcium and vitamin D (when fortified), supporting bone development and strength.
5. Versatile Food Source: Works well in cooking and baking applications, providing both nutrition and functional food properties.

Shared Benefits of Both Milk Types

1. Complete Protein Source: Both contain all essential amino acids needed for protein synthesis.
2. Calcium for Bone Health: Excellent sources of bioavailable calcium.
3. Vitamin B12: Important for nervous system function and blood cell formation.
4. Potassium: Supports heart and muscle function.
5. Hydration: Both contribute to daily fluid intake while providing nutrients.
6. Versatility: Can be consumed as beverages or used in various culinary applications.

A2 and A1 Milk brands in India

In India, both A1 and A2 milk are available, with A2 milk gaining popularity due to its perceived health benefits and association with indigenous cow breeds. Below is an overview of A2 and A1 milk brands in India:

A2 Milk Brands:

• Country Delight:
  • They emphasize sourcing A2 milk from Indian breeds like Gir and Sahiwal cows.
  • They focus on direct farm-to-doorstep delivery.
• Humpy Farms:
  • Specializes in organic A2 milk, particularly from Gir cows.
  • They highlight sustainable and ethical farming practices.
• GirOrganic:
  • Focuses specifically on A2 Gir cow milk.
  • They emphasize the purity and natural processing of their milk.
• Amul Deshi A2 Cow Milk:
  • Amul offers an A2 milk variant in select markets.
  • It is important to note that this is a specific product line of Amul.
• Native Milk:
  • This company focuses on A2 milk from indian desi cows.
  • They have a farm-to-home business model.

General Milk Brands (Where most of the milk sold is A1):

• Amul (General Milk):
  • While they have an A2 line, their primary milk products are what is considered general milk.
• Mother Dairy:
  • A very large provider of general milk in India.
• Dairy Best
• Britannia Milk
• Keventer Agro (Keventer Milk)

Availability and Cost: A2 Milk vs A1 Milk

A1 Milk Availability and Cost

1. Widespread Availability: A1 milk is widely available throughout India through government dairy cooperatives (like Mother Dairy and Amul), local dairy booths, supermarkets, and home delivery services.
2. Cost Range: Generally priced between ₹40-60 per litre for regular buffalo/cow milk in most Indian cities, with variations based on fat content and brand.
3. Market Penetration: Available even in small towns and villages through the extensive cooperative dairy network India has developed since the White Revolution.
4. Packaging Options: Available in multiple formats, including plastic pouches, tetra packs, and glass bottles; loose milk is also widely sold by local vendors.
5. Regional Coverage: Uniform availability across all regions of India with established cold chain networks.

A2 Milk Availability and Cost

1. Growing but Limited Availability: Primarily available in major metropolitan cities like Delhi, Mumbai, Bangalore, Hyderabad, and Chennai.
2. Premium Pricing: Significantly more expensive, typically priced between ₹80-140 per litre depending on the brand and city.
3. Specialty Channels: Often sold through specialty organic stores, select supermarkets, e-commerce platforms, and direct farm-to-home delivery services.
4. Indigenous Breeds: A2 milk from indigenous cow breeds (like Gir, Sahiwal, Red Sindhi) is gaining popularity but has limited distribution networks.
5. Regional Variations: More readily available in western and southern India compared to eastern and northeastern regions.
6. Emerging Brands: Companies like Akshayakalpa, Country Delight, Sarda Farms, and Pride of Cows are leading the A2 milk market with farm-to-table models.
7. Authentication Challenges: The market lacks standardized testing or certification for genuine A2 milk, leading to potentially misleading claims by some sellers.

Many traditional Indian households still prefer milk from local dairy farmers who maintain indigenous breeds producing naturally A2 milk, though this supply chain exists outside the organized retail sector, and prices vary considerably based on local economics.

Practical Recommendation

For most Indians, especially those on limited budgets, conventional A1 milk offers sufficient nutritional benefits at an accessible price point. However, for those who:

• Experience digestive discomfort with regular milk
• Can afford the premium pricing
• Have specific health concerns that might benefit from reduced inflammatory responses
• Value traditional indigenous breeding practices

A2 milk may be worth the additional cost. As production scales up and more indigenous breeds are preserved, A2 milk may become more accessible to wider segments of the population.

The ideal approach for India would be supporting indigenous cattle breeds and dairy infrastructure to make A2 milk more affordable and accessible nationwide, honoring both traditional practices and potential health benefits.

Conclusion

With growing awareness about food sensitivity and gut health, A2 milk has become a popular choice in India, especially among families looking for natural and traditional alternatives. While both A1 and A2 milk have nutritional value, A2 milk may offer better digestibility and health benefits for some individuals.

Choosing between A1 and A2 milk ultimately depends on your health condition, preferences, and budget. If you’re curious, try switching to A2 milk for a few weeks and observe how your body responds. As always, speak with your doctor or dietitian if you have any concerns.